Bed & Mattress Guides

Gel Foam vs. Innerspring Mattress: What's the Difference?

Gel Foam vs. Innerspring Mattress

Choosing the right mattress shouldn't be a battle with confusing info – it should be about achieving the deep, restful sleep you deserve! If you're torn between the pressure-relieving comfort of gel foam and the familiar support of an innerspring, you're not alone. Both offer unique benefits, but picking the best one for YOU is key.

You’ve got to pinpoint what your main style and concerns you have with sleeping - are you looking for a body-hugging feeling? Maybe the classic bounce? Concerned about overheating?

This guide breaks down the core differences between gel foam and innerspring mattresses, guiding you toward the type that matches your personal sleep needs.

  • Want a shortcut? Discover your perfect mattress MATCH in minutes with our SleepMatch Quiz.

Prefer to browse at your own pace? View our collection of gel foam mattresses, or check out the classic comfort of our innerspring mattresses.

The Foundations: Understanding Innerspring & Gel Foam

Innerspring mattresses represent a tried-and-true sleep solution, perfected over generations. Though often associated with an older style, modern innersprings offer excellent support and familiar comfort. 

Gel foam, on the other hand, is a newer innovation, taking the pressure-relieving power of memory foam and boosting its cooling qualities for a fresh take on comfort.

Innerspring Mattresses: Building Up Support

Innerspring mattresses are the classics! Built around a system of connected steel coils, they offer targeted support and distribute your weight effectively. Each coil acts independently, responding to pressure based on where you're positioned. For many, this translates to that familiar, reliable support found in traditional mattresses.

The spring structure typically allows for great airflow, helping hot sleepers, but be aware of how much the cushioning and top layer can limit this, or aid in cool nights sleep.

Gel Foam Mattresses: A Twist on Comfort

Gel foam takes a different approach! It starts with the base principle of memory foam – that slow-response, dense foam designed to contour to the body – and reinvents it. By integrating gels or gel-like substances, the core goal is to enhance temperature regulation and provide a slightly more responsive feel compared to classic memory foam.

How They Are Most Different

Where their paths diverge most drastically is construction:

  • Innerspring Mattresses: Primarily the coil network with potentially thin padding top and bottom. Minimal "sinking" occurs unless high-plush varieties.
  • Gel Foam Mattresses: Multiple dense foam layers. These create the unique body-hugging sensation. Support comes from the way the foam interacts with your body, rather than coils underneath.

Understanding Key Factors: Gel Foam vs. Innerspring

Comfort & Support

  • Gel Foam Mattresses: Excels at body contouring and pressure relief. Excellent for those seeking a "hugging" sensation, particularly side sleepers or those with aches. May feel restrictive for some who prefer sleeping "on top" of the mattress.
  • Innerspring Mattresses: Offers targeted support with less body contouring. Great for back and stomach sleepers needing firm alignment. Offers familiar bounce and easy movement. Some individuals may find it less pressure-relieving.

Temperature Regulation

  • Gel Foam Mattresses: Designed to improve breathability compared to traditional memory foam. Effectiveness depends on quality and type of gel, but ideal for those who find memory foam warm.
  • Innerspring Mattresses: Inherently provides excellent airflow due to the open coil system. Generally, the coolest sleeping mattress type, making it ideal for hot sleepers.


  • Gel Foam Mattresses: Distinct "sinking in," body-hugging sensation as the foam slowly contours. This can be both comforting and restrictive depending on personal preference.
  • Innerspring Mattresses: Responsive, bouncy feel with easy movement. Offers a classic, familiar mattress experience.

Motion Isolation

  • Gel Foam Mattresses: Typically excels in dampening movement, reducing disturbances from a restless partner.
  • Innerspring Mattresses: Varies greatly. Older models or low-quality ones transmit movement. However, modern designs (especially pocketed coils) minimize transfer significantly.


  • Both can have long lifespans. Look for high-density foams in gel mattresses, and well-constructed coil systems with strong materials in innersprings.


  • Gel Foam mattresses often fall into the mid-range price point.
  • Innerspring mattresses have the broadest range, both budget-friendly and high-end luxury options.

Choosing the Right Mattress for You

Finding the ideal mattress isn't a one-size-fits-all approach! There's no single "best" out there – the right one depends entirely on your personal needs and preferences. Let's break down those key decision factors:

Your Sleep Style: This makes a HUGE difference in comfort throughout the night:

  • Side Sleepers: Gel foam's pressure relief often leads the way! It cushions hips and shoulders. Ensure firmness matches your preference, as excessive sinkage can cause misalignment.
  • Back Sleepers: Both can work! Gel foam for a conforming feel, or innerspring for firm spinal support. Medium firmness generally suits most back sleepers.
  • Stomach Sleepers: Innersprings take the win for keeping the spine in a healthy position. Gel foam can work with EXTRA firm varieties, but many still find that sinking feeling problematic in this position.

Temperature Sensitivity: Are you a naturally hot sleeper or stay comfortably cool?

  • Hot Sleepers: Innersprings, with their excellent airflow, often lead in cooling. Explore high-quality gel foams if breathability is your top priority.
  • Naturally Cool: Both types can work well. Focus primarily on your support and "hug" preferences as temperature should be less of a concern.

Beyond the Basics:

  • Budget: Luckily, both types offer varied price points. Set a realistic range before falling in love with something unattainable.
  • "Feel" Preference: Does the body-hug comfort of gel foam appeal to you or do you miss the bounce of a traditional mattress? Don't ignore this personal preference!
  • Lifestyle Factors: Think about ease of moving the mattress if you frequently relocate and room size for potential issues with large or heavy options.

Important Reminder: No mattress description can accurately replace actually trying one out! Generous sleep trials offered by many brands are key for knowing whether a mattress truly matches your needs long-term. Whenever possible, test both gel foam and innerspring mattress options to experience the difference firsthand.

Dispelling Mattress Myths & Revealing Caveats

Let's debunk common myths and clarify a few points so you make decisions free of unnecessary fear or false optimism.

Myth #1: All gel foam mattresses are perfectly cooling.

Truth: While gel foam mattresses aim to improve on memory foam's potential for heat build-up, not all are equal. Cheaper designs, or those with minimal or low-quality gel may disappoint. Always look for good user reviews focusing on breathability, and opt for trusted brands if temperature control is top-priority.

Myth #2: Innerspring mattresses are always noisy.

Truth: Older models earned this reputation! Advances in coil construction and pocketed coil designs greatly reduce noise potential for modern innersprings. If this is a major concern, make sure to inquire about the coil system when considering any innerspring mattress.

Myth #3: Price = Quality, especially for gel foam mattresses.

Truth: Price matters, but don't assume the most expensive means best for YOU. High-quality materials cost more, but less expensive can still be great - IF they address your needs. Focus on your comfort preference first, THEN look for the best value within that focus.

Important Caveats To Consider

  • Gel Foam Feel: It's unique! Terms like "hug" can mean different things to people. If possible, always try one to avoid surprises. Different densities of foam / gel can also create wildly different feelings. When in doubt, test them out!
  • Innerspring Support: Firmness can vary a lot! Even if one was too soft in the past, a different model could be ideal. Don't rule them out entirely based on one experience.
  • Innerspring Breathability: While coils naturally promote airflow, thick cushioning layers on some models can reduce this advantage. Always consider a mattress's construction holistically (coils AND comfort layers) if heat reduction is a key factor for you.
  • Marketing Fluff: Ignore vague terms like "orthopedic." Focus on tangible evidence – coil gauge, foam densities, user reviews describing actual pressure relief, etc.

Link to: 

Other Mattress Options to Consider

While gel foam and innerspring mattress options may be your leading contenders, the mattress world has so much to offer! Don't limit yourself if neither sounds perfect for you. Here are a few worth exploring:

  • Hybrid Mattresses: The ultimate combination. Hybrids utilize an innerspring base with multiple comfort layers. These often feature gel foam for cooling, along with other foams for targeted support.
  • Memory Foam Mattresses : The foundation from which gel foam evolved. If budget is a major focus, it offers similar pressure relief, especially good for side sleepers who value that sink-in feel. Consider it if "coolness" is less of a priority, or if a trusted brand delivers exceptional quality for affordable prices.
  • Bed-in-a-Box: This refers to the delivery method (compressed), not a specific mattress type. This convenience often comes with free trials and competitive pricing - worth considering if budget friendliness is high on your list.

When exploring beyond gel or innerspring mattress sets, remain focused on those core needs in our "Choosing the Right Mattress" section (sleep style, temperature, etc.). These categories might offer the perfect solution or help you confidently eliminate what definitely won't work.

FAQs: Gel Foam vs. Innerspring Mattresses

Q: Which mattress is best, gel foam or innerspring?

A: It depends! Gel foam excels in pressure relief and often temperature regulation, making it great for side sleepers and hot sleepers. Innersprings offer classic support and airflow, ideal for back sleepers or those who prefer a less enveloping feel.

Q: Gel foam mattresses sound perfect, but what about that "stuck" feeling people mention?

A: It is a reality for many gel mattresses - but not all! For side sleepers, this can be desirable. Stomach sleepers or active sleepers may find it uncomfortable. Density impacts response – firmer varieties reduce it. Always try one if possible before the final purchase.

Q: Are all innerspring mattresses breathable?

A: Many are super airy, BUT thick comfort layers on top can diminish this advantage. Ask or look into the mattress construction – breathable fabrics and less cushioning mean maximum coolness, especially vital for those of us who sleep warm.

Q: I want the perfect mix of softness and support, where should I start?

A: Hybrids might be your answer! They combine the plush comfort of gel foams with the support of an innerspring core. Check out our wide, curated selection of both Gel Foam Mattresses and Hybrid mattresses to find your match.

Q: Overwhelmed by choices and need real-life guidance?

A: Let us help! Visit our showroom for individual advice from sleep experts. Experience firsthand how gel foam and innerspring feel by testing out diverse models, including top brands. 

Finding Your Perfect Sleep Solution

Choosing between gel foam and innerspring doesn't need to feel like an endless quest. Remember, there's no single "best" mattress out there for everyone – there's just the best one for YOU! Use the knowledge you've gained to confidently pick the type that matches your individual needs.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Need Quick Clarity? Take our short SleepMatch Quiz and get personalized recommendations instantly.

  • Prefer to Browse? Explore our curated collections - discover the latest in both cooling gel foams Gel Foam Mattresses and the reliable support of Innerspring Mattresses.
  • Want In-Person Testing? Visit our showroom to compare top models and get personalized advice from our sleep experts.

Remember, a good mattress isn't just a purchase, it's a direct investment in your health and well-being. Say goodbye to restless nights and hello to waking up refreshed and ready to tackle your day!

Related Mattress Comparisons:

Feb 7, 2024